• IRFU / Big Four (Toronto Argonauts, Hamilton Tige-Cats, Ottawa Rough Riders and Montreal Alouettes)
• ORFU (Toronto Balmy Beach, Sarnia Imperials, Kitchener-Wateroo Dutchmen)
• All-East composed of IRFU, ORFU and University Teams. First and second teams were selected.
• West / WIFU .(Saskatchewan, Winnipeg, Calgary, Edmonton and BC)
• Ted Reeves - taken from all teams in Canada. There were no official All-Canadians until 1962.
• Shrine East and West - Players picked for the East-West All-Star game

The Big Four / IRFU and the WIFU / West picked both offensive and defensive squads, the ORFU and Reeves picked only a single 12 player squad.  The All-East team had first and second teams rather than separate offensive and defensive teams, though several of hte players on the second team appeared to be chosen for their defensive play.  A notable case in point is Hal Patterson as a second team halfback - Patterson was a farmous offensive end, but played defensive back as well in this t wo way era.  Ted Reeves tended to pick seven lineman, not caring much about position, so you have two centers in Tom Hugo and Bob Dean and there is only one true end in Red O'Quinn. That is why the chart below shows LM (lineman) for seven positions - these are for the Reeves team and the regular positions are for the other all-star squads.  There was also some inconsistency in the picking of the flying wing position.  The West tended to just pick four halfbacks, so the slot after QB is marked FW / HB.  Leo Lewis was not a flying wing, but one of the four hafbacks picked. For the Big Four and West, if only one player is listed, he was both the division and palyed in the Shrine game.  Players marked with a + were added for the Shrine game only due to players not being available or so a player who was both an all-star on offence and defence didn't have to play both ways.  For example, Kent Burris was a West All-Star at both center and linebacker, so Mel Beckett was added at center.

Offence

Defence