After playing three years at Queen's University, Chantler went on to play two years (1927-28) for the Toronto Argonauts. In 1929, Chantler moved across town to play for Balmy Beach. In 1930, Chantler tried out with the Kitchener Panthers of the ORFU, but had to retire due to his health. Chantler played and coached the St. Thomas Intermediate team in 1931 as they won the Candadian Intermediate Football title. Chantler tried a comeback at the senior level with the Hamilton Tigers in 1932, but didn't make it and returned to St. Thomas where he played quarterback and led them to their second straight Intermediate title.. In 1933, Chantler played at least in exhibition games with Toronto Balmy Beach.
Chantler Turns In Splendid Game For Queen's vs. Beaches - December 1, 1924
Pee Wee Chantler To Don Argo Uniforn - September 8, 1927
Chantler In Workouts With Argos - September 13, 1928
Chantler & St. Thomas Wins Intermediate Title - December 7, 1931
Chantler In Running For Head Coach of Queens to Replace Ted Reeve - August 3, 1939
Chantlet & St. Thomas Repeat As Intermediate Champions - December 12, 1932
| Year | Team | GP |
|---|---|---|
| 1924 | QU | |
| 1925 | QU | |
| 1926 | QU | |
| 1927 | TOR | |
| 1928 | TOR | |
| 1929 | TBB | |
| 1931 | STH* | |
| 1932 | STH* | |
| 1933 | TBB |
* St. Thomas Intermediate Team