| Hayman, Lew | 1946-51 | Sept. 30, 1908 | New York, NY | June 29, 1984 | More |
| Walker, Douglas (Peahead) | 1952-59 | Feb. 17, 1899 | Ensley, AL | July 16, 1970 | More |
| Moss, Perry | 1960-62 | Aug. 4, 1926 | Tulsa, OK | Aug. 7, 2014 | More |
| Trimble, Jim | 1963-65 | May 29, 1918 | McKeesport, PA | May 23, 2006 | More |
| Mudra, Darrell | 1966 | Jan. 14, 1929 | Omaha, NE | More | |
| Dalton, Kay Orris (O.K.) | 1967-69 | May 4, 1932 | Moab, UT | More | |
| Etcheverry, Sam | 1970-72 | May 20, 1930 | Carlsbad, NM | Aug. 29, 2009 | More |
| Levy, Marv | 1973-77 | Aug. 3, 1925 | Chicago, IL | More | |
| Scannella, Joe | 1978-81 | May 22, 1928 | Passaic, NJ | More | |
| Eddy, Jim F. | 1981 | May 2, 1936 | Checotah, OK | More | |
| Galat, Joe | 1982-84 | Apr. 22, 1939 | Cresson, PA | More | |
| Durchik, Gary | 1985-86 | May 30, 1944 | Martinsburg, WV | More | |
| Faragalli, Joe | 1987 | Apr. 18, 1929 | Philadelphia, PA | April 10, 2006 | More |
| Price, Bob | 1996 | July 24, 1955 | New York, NY | More | |
| Ritchie, Dave | 1997-98 | Sept. 3, 1938 | New Bedford, MA | More | |
| Taaffe, Charlie | 1999-00 | Apr. 20, 1950 | Albany, NY | More | |
| Rust, Rod | 2001 | Aug. 2, 1928 | Webster City, IA | More | |
| Popp, Jim | 2001,06-07, 13 | Dec. 21, 1964 | Elkin, NC | More | |
| Matthews, Don | 2002-06 | June 22, 1939 | Amesbury, MA | More | |
| Trestman, Marc | 2008-12 | Jan. 15, 1956 | Minneapolis, MN | More | |
| Hawkins, Dan | 2013 | Nov. 10, 1960 | Fall River Mills, CA | More | |
| Higgins, Tom | 2014-15 | July 13, 1954 | Colonia, NJ | More |
